Tinder has launched a new advertising/social awareness campaign, they’re calling #menprovement.
The premise is that there a lot of douchebags on Tinder, and so there’s a scientifically themed effort to improve the quality of men on Tinder.
It features videos of women scientists like these:
And charts like these:
Now obviously this is intended to be a fairly lighthearted kind of campaign – but humour like this doesn’t exist in a vacuum. The reason that this campaign is considered a good idea, is because there is genuine sentiment that there are too many douchey men on Tinder.
A starting point – let’s acknowledge the existence of douchey men and abuse women face on the internet.
I want to be clear. I acknowledge that women on the internet, and on dating apps like Tinder, likely face a lot of verbal/written abuse in the face of rejection, sleazy messages, unsolicited dick pics etc.
I’m generally of the opinion that men and women have opposite problems on online dating – where women suffer through unwanted attention – men suffer from a vacuum of attention, and loneliness.
If we consider the wider issue of rape culture / consent culture – it’s very reasonable to consider conducting social campaigns aimed at changing the way people behave, and in this case, the way men behave in the context of a dating app.
So getting that out of the way – I acknowledge that there’s a problem of douchey behaviour from men on dating apps like Tinder, and it would be a good thing to improve on that.
Tinder’s campaign does not address actual douchey behaviour
This image is probably the egregious example:
Wanting a partner who has a job and is nice to your mother? Great – that’s just the kind of thing we want to encourage.
Being six feet tall? – Is that really the problem with Tinder? That there’s not enough tall men? Are short men guilty of being douchebags?
I’m not going to pretend that we shouldn’t have physical qualities that we find attractive, and I’m not offended by the proposition that many women prefer a man taller than them.
The issue I have with this image is the gross insensitivity it demonstrates.
For example, where I think the fat acceptance movement is dangerous; I think obesity should be treated as a health condition, not an acceptable lifestyle, I think all people should be treated with respect – and not be the subject of cruel jokes.
So while I think it’s ok for someone to have a preference for slim women for example – I don’t think it’s ok to make fat jokes. The same goes for short men – show some sensitivity.
Let’s examine some qualities of what Tinder considers douches
- A self employed CEO
- Has a bluetooth
- Tips minimum
- Late because charging vape
- Is into fitness, and you should be too
- Posts gym sessions on instagram
- ‘This body wasn’t built for monogamy’
- Eggplant emojis as opener
- Come hungry as closer
Of this list, I’d say tipping minimum is perhaps the only actual douche behavior, and eggplant emoji, depending on whether you’re into that kind of thing.
Here’s where Tinder needs to get it straight:
There’s nothing wrong with being into the gym, being non-monogamous, or owning your own business.
It’s straight up misandric bullshit to try shame men for possessing these qualities – things that they’re probably quite proud of.
If I’m to hazard a guess here – that these stereotypes are seen as acceptable targets – because they’re ‘successful men’ – and can therefore take take being taken down a notch.
However – what Tinder needs to realise – is that it’s not just men fitting the stereotype, or men who water rolls of the duck’s back of, that sees these videos.
I think we need to consider men in the context of having higher rates of suicide, and higher rates of computer and video game addiction. Within that context – we shouldn’t be trying to tear men’s sense of self esteem and value away from them. If men get that from owning their own business, or working out – that that should be encouraged, not criticised for being douchey.
What it suggests to me – is that Tinder’s willingness to go along with this campaign – means that they don’t value men’s feelings nearly as highly as women’s. That again reinforces the social norm of male disposability.
Douchey behaviour that Tinder could have used.
The thing is – this could have been quite an interesting and positive campaign – if Tinder had seeked to address actual toxic or unappealing behaviour.
Here’s a quick list, if they need inspiration:
- Boring first messages, ‘Sup’, ‘How are you’ guy.
- Main hobbies are playing video games and trolling on the internet, and nothing outside of that guy.
- Ten days unwashed dishes guy.
- Responds with abuse at rejection guy.
- Only wants to talk about you guy.
- Only wants to talk about him guy.
- Never suggests going on a date guy.
- Insists on a first date at your place guy.
- Is cheating on his girlfriend guy.
- Selfish lover guy.
How women can foster non-douchey behaviour Tinder
Let’s get this ball rolling.
- Send the first message. Set the frame for the conversation. Want flirty banter? Want a challenging argument? Want a standard get to know each other conversation? Your message determines that.
- Unmatch severe douches. Train men with negative reinforcement.
- Call out mild douchey behaviour. See if there’s a correction of behaviour.
- Respond to desired behaviour with positive reinforcement. Personally, I like the 😍 emoji
God. This must be what being a Cosmopoliton writer must feel like.
‘But it’s just a joke David, stop taking it so seriously’.
Jokes are never just jokes. Jokes are generally funny because they have a kernel of truth (or what the joke teller purports to be the truth).
Just like how telling racist jokes creates a hostile environment for black people, or telling sexist jokes creates a hostile environment for women – these guys of jokes create an hostile environment for men.
Now – I would suggest that there’s a brand of feminism that is ok with this – men need to be taken down a notch because either that’s justice, or because that makes it easier for women to achieve equality. I don’t want to get get into this line of argument here – but I would make two points – that this is likely to be not effective, it’s just likely to cause division between men and women, and that this philosophy directly contradicts the argument that ‘feminism is for the interests of both men and women’.
Reactions from the internet
The reactions on their Twitter and Facebook threads has been almost entirely negative – mostly pointing out that it’s sexist and douchey in itself. There’s also a lot of comments from men saying how they don’t get matches – would would seem to confirm comment I made in the first section.
This does take us to a point of personal conflict for me. While I clearly agree with the commenters in this instance – in other gendered hot topics on the internet – there is often a reaction of faux victimisation from what can be fairly considered alt-right types. (I’m struggling to think of examples here right now though – maybe revisit this later).
A pretty gross campaign.
Not the right way to go about creating a society of confident, respectful men, at all.
I’m curious to hear from my feminist friends about this. While Tinder has faced a bit of criticism on social media about this – the feminist community as a whole are quite quiet about it. There’s definitely no social media storm about it – which does suggest that people simply don’t care about this kind of toxic gender dynamic.
There is though – the chance that this is a long running deeper social critique – that explores things like gender norms around height attraction, and all will be revealed in time. If I was taking a bet, I’d bet against that happening though.